• Sun. Nov 16th, 2025

Compare Factory

The Blog for the Indecisive

Car Pet Covers vs. Carriers: Which Is Better?

PetSafe Happy Ride Bench Seat Cover - Tan - PTV17-16869source: barkcontrol.com.au

Okay, so you’ve been thinking about taking your pup with you on our weekend road trip… But there’s more to travelling with pets than just tossing them in the backseat and heading off. You’ve got to plan a bit—make sure they’re safe and your car doesn’t turn into a fur-covered mess. If you’ve been going back and forth between using a carrier and just getting one of those pet car seat covers, you’re not alone. 

Both have their perks. Some people like the security of a carrier, others prefer the freedom of a seat cover. It really comes down to what your pet’s comfortable with—and what works best for your car, too. So, whether you order a car cover for pets or a pet carrier, it’s all about finding the right balance between keeping them safe and not turning your car into a disaster zone. 

What is a Car Dog Seat Cover?

Kurgo Extended Bench Seat Cover - Hampton Sand - K01264
source: barkcontrol.com.au

Well, it’s more of a protective blanket for your car seats. You lay it over the back seat to shield it from fur, dirt, scratches, and any mess your dog might make. And there are different types of seat covers. There are bench-style covers that fit over the back seat, hammock-style ones that hang between the front and back seats to prevent your dog from falling into the footwell, and even single-seat covers for front seats. 

Most have straps that attach to the headrests and anchors that tuck into the seat crevices, so they stay put pretty well. Some even have non-slip backing for extra grip. They’re super safe and comfy, and that’s exactly why a lot of people choose a car seat cover for pets over a pet carrier. 

What Is a Pet Carrier for the Car?

It’s basically a little travel box or bag for your pet. You pop them in, zip them up, and it keeps them safe and in one place while you drive. Most of them have handles or straps so you can carry your pet around easily, too. And they’re super handy if your dog or cat gets anxious in the car. It gives them a cosy little spot to feel secure. So, it’s more about keeping them contained and calm. And some even clip into the seatbelt so they stay put while you’re driving. No jumping around the back seat!

Car Dog Seat Covers vs. Pet Carriers

Kurgo Rover Bench Seat Cover - Charcoal - POG30-17772
source: barkcontrol.com.au

Safety and Comfort 

Ok, for starters, they both have their perks. A pet carrier keeps your dog or cat in one spot, so they can’t move around too much. That’s great for keeping them calm and secure. But a car covers for pets lets them stretch out a bit and feel less trapped. Some even come with harness clips, so your dog stays in place but comfy too. And if you’re thinking which one you should choose, it also depends on the pet; some love the space, others feel better in their cosy carrier.

Cleanliness and Car Protection

Okay, real talk, cleaning fur and muddy paw prints from the car is the worst. That’s why seat covers are a lifesaver. They cover the back seat completely, so all the mess stays off your actual car seats. Although pet carriers are pretty easy to clean, too, especially the ones with washable pads inside. The difference is, with a cover, your pet can still move around a bit. With a carrier, the mess is more contained, but the cleanup’s still needed after.

Best for Short Trips vs. Long Journeys

Dog owners often wonder whether they should use a carrier or a seat cover for a long road trip. If it’s a long trip, maybe it’s best to go with car dog seat cover. If your dog likes to stretch out and nap, they would go nuts in a carrier for hours. But if it’s just for quick drives, like a trip to the vet, the carrier feels easier—just grab and go. Carriers are perfect when you need to pop them in and out fast. Seat covers are better if you’re driving all day and want them to be comfy without getting your car dirty.

Which One Works for You, and Do Dog Car Seat Covers Work?

KONG Bench Seat Cover & Hammock
source: barkcontrol.com.au

Oh, they absolutely do. They are in fact a total game changer. For starters, no more fur all over the seats. And the waterproof ones? Lifesavers when it’s raining or after a beach day. I just shake them off or wipe them down, and boom—clean car. Also, most come with straps that hook around the headrests and anchor you push between the seat cushions. 

They don’t slide around, even when my dog does his zoomies back there. Now, the real question is: between that and a carrier, how do you know which one’s right? Honestly, it depends on the trip and your pet. If your dog likes to move around or lie flat, seat cover all the way. But if your pet’s anxious or teeny tiny, a carrier might feel safer for them.

By Jessie Sanner

Always weighing things, the life of a Libra isn’t easy and that’s something Jessie is well acquainted with as a Libra herself. The confusion with having to choose between things is what helps her write for the blog, in the hope of making it easier for readers who are indecisive themselves. Interested in contrasts, like period dramas and sci-fi, casual and classy outfits, fries and detox shakes, the life of this young lady is anything but boring. Or is it?