Travelling is an integral part of many musicians’ careers, whether for live performances, concerts, tours, rehearsals, or recording sessions. During these travels, their violas are frequently exposed to potential risks such as physical damage, environmental changes, and theft. This makes high-quality protective cases essential in preserving the instrument’s condition and performance quality.
When it comes to choosing the right viola case, there are two main types to consider, hardshell cases and softshell cases. They differ in several key aspects, like the level of protection, portability, durability, and cost. Understanding the differences between these two types can help you buy a viola case that meets your needs and lifestyle.
Softshell Viola Cases
These viola cases are designed for musicians who prioritise portability, lightweight convenience, and affordability. They are usually made from durable, padded fabric such as nylon, polyester, or canvas.
To protect the instrument from minor impacts and scratches the interior usually features foam or quilted padding. Although this padding provides cushioning against everyday bumps and jostling, usually is less rigid than that of hardshell cases, which affects the level of protection they offer. The padding can vary in thickness and quality depending on the model.
Next, they are often lighter than hardshell cases, making them easier to carry over long distances or for longer periods.
Style-wise, these models are available in various colours, patterns, and styles, allowing musicians to choose a case that reflects their taste. Compared to the polished look of hardshell cases, softshell options often have a more casual or sporty appearance.
Cost-wise, softshell viola cases are more affordable than hardshell models, making them a popular choice for students, amateur musicians, or those on a budget.
On the downside, softshell cases can show signs of wear and tear more quickly compared to hardshell cases. They are more prone to stains, rips, and dirt, which over time may have an impact on their appearance.
Additionally, because airlines frequently handle bags roughly, they’re not the best option for checked baggage or air travel. Softshell cases lack a strong construction meaning they are not sturdy enough to support the viola when handled roughly. If something heavy falls on the case, it could potentially damage the instrument inside.
Hardshell Viola Cases
Hardshell viola cases are often considered the perfect choice for many musicians, especially those who prioritise protection and durability for their instruments. Premium hardshell cases are made from high-strength materials like carbon fibre, Kevlar, fibreglass, or a combination of composite materials. These materials are lightweight and offer excellent protection from damage. Carbon fibre, for instance, is a popular material for high-end cases because it provides a great balance between weight and durability.
Another great advantage of hardshell cases is their long-lasting durability. As already mentioned they’re constructed from high-quality materials known for their high impact resistance, strength, and ability to withstand rough handling, making them far less prone to wear and tear than soft-shell alternatives. They don’t easily scratch, or deform, providing long-term durability that justifies their often higher price.
Due to their structural support and snug fit, these carrying solutions provide stability for the viola, preventing it from moving around. Unlike soft cases that can flex or deform under pressure, hardshell models maintain consistent structural stability regardless of external conditions.
This feature reduces the risk of damage during transport making these cases ideal for air travel and checked baggage. If you travel by air frequently, then a hardshell case is almost essential.
Style-wise, hardshell cases often come in sleek, professional designs, offering enhanced aesthetic appeal. Available in a variety of colours, finishes, and styles, these options appeal to musicians looking for a more refined appearance.
Furthermore, many hardshell viola cases come with advanced features, further improving the level of protection, convenience, and customisation. These advanced features cater to professional viola players who need more than just a basic case and serious students who require top-tier security and functionality for their valuable instrument.
These advanced cases often have internal suspension systems that cradle the instrument securely in place and provide a cushion against shocks and impacts. Furthermore, they often have extra reinforcements around the most vulnerable parts of the viola, such as the bridge and neck areas, TSA-approved locks, and even Velcro neck restraints or anti-slip materials to ensure that the instrument does not move around.
However, hardshell cases also come with certain downsides that might make them less suitable for some musicians. Due to their rigid construction, they’re generally heavier than softshell options. Furthermore, the added protection also adds weight which can be cumbersome for musicians who need to carry their cases for extended periods.
Their bulkiness can also be inconvenient for violists who travel frequently and need to pack their instruments into tight car trunks, overhead compartments on aeroplanes, or crowded practice spaces. This can make storage and transport more challenging.